Disloyal management in contexts of legal uncertainty: legal judgment rule and permitted risk

Keywords: disloyal management, business judgment rule, legal judgment rule, duty of legality, legal uncertainty

Abstract

Corporate directors routinely make decisions in contexts of legal uncertainty. Although uncertainty as to legality does not exclude external liability for the unlawful act committed, a substantial part of corporate law scholarship holds that such decisions —despite potentially proving detrimental to the company in hindsight— should not necessarily give rise to internal liability for the director, either under the business judgment rule or through the judicial recognition of the so-called legal judgment rule. This paper argues that the latter doctrine should be used to delineate the scope of permissible risk in the criminal offence of disloyal management (breach-of-trust). A decision taken ex ante on the basis of a reasonable assessment of the company’s interests in a situation of insurmountable legal uncertainty does not violate the fiduciary duty whose breach constitutes the offence, even if the decision is subsequently deemed unlawful and the resulting sanction causes harm to the company.

Received: 16.06.2026
Accepted: 03.09.2026

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Ivó Coca Vila, Universidad Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona. Spain

Profesor agregado de Derecho penal

Published
2026-11-13
How to Cite
Coca Vila, Ivó. 2026. “Disloyal Management in Contexts of Legal Uncertainty: Legal judgment Rule and Permitted Risk”. Estudios De Deusto, November. https://doi.org/10.18543/ed.3749.
Section
Studies